My sister once asked me about the parallels between baseball and fantasy baseball. I told her that it’s sort of like the parallels between talk and talk radio — there are indeed similarities, but one should never be mistaken for the other.
Which might help explain how the beleaguered, banged-up squad of misfits known as The Vermin managed to stumble into the top tier in the closing days of the regular season.
The 2010 campaign marked my eighth year in a 10-team keeper league comprised mostly of current and former colleagues. I finished second in my inaugural season, then quickly transitioned from idiot savant to just plain idiot.

My fantasy team got an unexpected lift from a guy whose mouth has greater velocity than his fastball.
Two years ago, however, The Vermin captured the league title. But in 2009, my comeuppance came in the form of a computer malfunction during the online draft that enabled the auto-pick robot to stock my roster with has-beens and never-gonna-bes. So this season, I did my homework (and upgraded my software) in the hopes of proving that the championship year wasn’t just a fluke.
Like baseball itself, such things often prove to be more challenging than they seem.
Pain and Suffering
Cliff Lee, Jose Reyes and Houston Street started the season on the Disabled List. The first two came back strong; the other one would labor through the peaks and valleys of the Rockies. Justin Morneau essentially missed the second half after suffering a concussion, and several other Vermin would spend time on the DL. In many ways, this season felt like watching “M*A*S*H*” without the laugh track.
Kings of the Hill
A position player can strike out five times in a game and the only damage your team suffers will be a tiny dip in batting average. On the other hand, a single bad outing from a pitcher can seriously bring the pain in earned run average and walks/hits ratio. My long-term strategy for developing a strong core of pitching paid off this season: Lee, CC Sabathia, Mariano Rivera and Dan Haren (even though Danny Boy had an off-year by his standards.) Also, draftee Billy Wagner had a terrific campaign in what looks to be his final season. At least he can retire as a Vermin.
My Little One-Trick Pony
Aaron Hill left the yard 26 times, but apparently misplaced his batting average while he was out there (.205 for the season). Carlos Pena managed two more dingers than Hill while amassing a .196 average. Amassing? More like a-minoring. Hill also proved to be less of a threat on the basepaths (2 steals) than the comparatively fleet-footed Pena (5 steals) and the cheetah-like Mike Napoli (4 steals).
Diamond Mine
Waiver-wire scrounging produced a few pleasant surprises, including Casey McGehee, Luke Scott, Trevor Cahill and Chris Perez. Kerry Wood came on in relief, then quickly exited in comic relief. Dallas Braden? The perfect game provided a real lift, while the Alex Rodriguez feud and the steady stream of snarky sound-bites had great entertainment value. Shine on, you crazy diamond.
Irrelevant Never Forgets
My final draft pick, Brett Gardner, proved to be much more than an afterthought (47 steals and 97 runs scored). He did strike out 101 times, but I’ve decided to make peace with the whiff since it seems to have become a Vermin trademark.
Fantasy vs. Reality
In the end, I managed to finish fourth despite the injuries, the busted draft picks and having several players from subpar MLB clubs manning key positions. These included three Orioles, an Indian, a National not named Strasburg and a Mariner not named Hernandez.
But that’s fantasy baseball – a collection of individual performers who exist as teammates only in the metaphysical sense. Sometimes they add up to more than the sum of their parts, sometimes less.
And sometimes they add up to Vermin.
And so endeth the 2010 season. Until next time, my fellow diamond dweebs, remember to hit ‘em where they ain’t.